Zomgee
christmas-music

Christmas Music?

by HT on Dec.26, 2007, under Food & Holiday

It’s been Christmastime for quite a while now and so naturally I think we have all heard our fair share of Christmas music for the year. Now I like Christmas music. I like the Christian spiritual type, I like the upbeat secular type, I like the Santa type, I like old songs and I like new songs. All in all Christmas music can be great, but what I can’t understand is why musicians have to but their heads in and ruin the music. You’re probably wondering how that makes any manner of sense at all, well let me explain myself.

There are certain songs that are, how shall we say, iconic. These songs have been heard and sung by everyone under the sun. We know them, and we love them. These are songs like “White Christmas,” “Silent Night,” and “Rudolf the Red Nosed Reindeer.” As it turns out there is something about musicians that dictates that at least once in their career must needs do a Christmas CD and as it turns out most of these musicians are not creative enough to write their own songs, so they sing the old favorites. Now there would be absolutely nothing wrong with this, because who doesn’t want to hear their favorite artist sing their favorite Christmas songs, but why is it that these musicians, who may write good music normally, have to absolutely butcher these songs.

Where is it written that they have to somehow “make the song theirs?” Now I understand they’re just trying to make it fit with their style of music but if its a song that doesn’t fit into your style of music – WRITE YOUR OWN. I’m tired of hearing crappy renditions of wonderful songs just because some moron musician thought it would be a great idea to put a little flair into it. Yes I’m looking at you Elvis. He’s certainly not the only one, in fact far from it, but he is a good example because his entire Christmas CD is absolutely terrible all because he made great songs sound horrible by putting them in his “style.”

Please, please if you ever decide to become a musician and ever decide to do a Christmas CD let me just give you a little hint: If Frank Sinatra, Bing Crosby, or Nat King Cole has already sung the song, then either don’t bother or for goodness sake do the song justice and no adding in your own flavor of melisma does not count as doing the song justice in fact it counts as reason to stop singing altogether because contrary to popular belief it (a) does not sound good and (b) does not mean you’re a good singer because you can do it. I think ultimately we’d just plain be better off if singers would just get the rights and put the Frank Sinatra, Bing Crosby, or Nat King Cole versions of their songs straight on their CD instead of making our ears bleed with their own atrocities. Please just go home, learn how to sing, or create something creative – plenty of musicians can actually do that after all.

  • Share/Bookmark
12 comments for this entry:
  1. Dan

    You just summed up everything that is wrong with Christmas music and why I absolutely detest 99% of it. Clay Aiken earned the status of “idiot” when he redid both “Mary Did You Know” and “All Is Well”- the only 2 Christmas songs that I enjoy. When I think of Mary Did You Know, I think of Mark Lowry. When I think of All Is Well, I think of Michael Crawford. I will never think of anyone else, and if anyone else even attempts to perform those songs to an audience of over 200, they will be shunned by me for life.
    Go ahead… try me.

    Dan’s last blog post.. Merry Christmas!

  2. ZePuKa

    Yeah that pretty much covers it. Although some butcherings can be quiet amusing, I’ll say that…

  3. Happy Mama

    Some butchering i detest come from Denver and the mile high orchestra…..They put swing into everything..most of which doesn’t belong! Can you imagine them remaking the Christmas shoes?

    Happy Mama’s last blog post.. About to Scream!

  4. Dan

    To add to that comment- you might not have heard, but they canceled all their concerts in NY because they were busy with some American Idol:Band Edition-like TV show.

    Dan’s last blog post.. Merry Christmas!

  5. Happy Mama

    yeah fairly disappointed in them.. They canceled all their concerts not just in Ny and came out 2nd best anyway! The ones in New york were supposed to have a choir of 100 people from all over the state performing with them..This group must have felt let down big time since they had been practicing since the middle of October or something like that!

    Happy Mama’s last blog post.. About to Scream!

  6. OhYo

    Nat King Cole and others sang some of the “older favorites” of that time and it stuck with their rendition; everyone nowadays isn’t as influential and jealous. I notice in some stores (including CB) play or make their own versions of any type of music to subliminally prod customers into a buying/spending mood. Its all about atmosphere and when when jingle bells is spammed fast it makes people think in the back of their head that “the holidays” are coming quick so they’d better buy something.

    OhYo’s last blog post.. Holiday News Filler

  7. Stephanie

    I’ll agree, but since I dislike Christmas music in general (no radio from November 28 to January 3!), I’d be a bad one to comment . . .

  8. ZePuKa

    I must say that this is the absolute lowest of lows in Christmas music renditions…

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=afLS80uSWZM

  9. ZePuKa

    That’s a pretty good argument, but at least they stuck mostly to the traditional melody…. FF5 didn’t… o_x

  10. Christmas Music?-Download Music

    [...] Justin Gehring wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptIt’s been Christmastime for quite a while now and so naturally I think we have all heard our fair share of Christmas music for the year. Now I like Christmas music. I like the Christian spiritual type, I like the upbeat secular type, … [...]

  11. michael

    This post is really a must bookmarked for me! Thank you so much. :D

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!

Visit our friends!

A few highly recommended friends...